why ai is not growing businesses

AI so far has been a zero sum game. Replace people with AI, lower cost, make more profit. However, according to this Apollo study, that’s not happening, and not only is the AI not increasing the top line, it’s not increasing the bottom line either. In talking to business owners for two decades, and building my own business to millions in revenue, I think I see the reason why.

AI presented itself as a cure-all, hand over the keys to the AI, let it drive. The “human in the loop” phrase became kind of a joke, where people weren’t sure what that means. And that was where it all went wrong. People ripped out the thinkers and replaced them with AI, which naturally leads to lower output. It’s basically the same as hiring a more junior person to just run a task, versus a more senior person who thinks about the task and how to optimize it. Yes, if you bring in the more junior person it can run on autopilot, but you get less results, and by the time you train them and pay for other external costs, it ends up not making you much more profit. At least that’s the case with AI.

The other issue I see is that AI sets the precedent of a one-shot approach. Explain everything in detail, let it run, and get a result. But that’s not how people buy. People buy in a serpentine, uneven, unpredictable, way. If you expect to just set everything up once, let it run, and have people buy, you’re grossly mistaken. But AI promised that outcome, and people took the bait.

In all my experience, and for all my friends who run businesses, sales is a process that takes both the predictable, with things like documentation and product guides, and also the unpredictable, like answering random customer questions and jumping on the phone at 3:11pm for 6 minutes to answer a question that could have been an email but the customer wants emotional reassurance they are not going to get screwed by buying your solution so they want to chat quickly.

AI was so appealing, because it made it seem like all the difficulty and uncertainty could be removed from the business building process. The inability to truly know what’s going on could be taken out of the process, and you could have smooth sailing to business and profit growth. You can’t fake real human interaction. AI is AI, it’s not a person. I don’t care what you say, or how hard you try to shill your product by posting a screenshot showing how the AI booked a meeting or made a sale, that’s not what’s happening in the real world. In the real world, people are saying “speak to a human” more than anything, and if they even catch wind of being sold by an AI, they are upset.

You still have to show up, put yourself out there, be a real person. That’s what people want to buy from, that’s what people want to hear from, that’s what convinces people to hand over the money they feel like is getting harder and harder to come by. And the numbers are now starting to reveal that you can definitely replace everything with AI, but it won’t increase revenue or profits the way it’s being pitched.

Next
Next

lessons from 14 years bootstrapping a company